By Carrie Lazar, CDMP, PCM, Sr Communications Manager, USSFCU

Alexandria, VA – Buy Now, Pay Later services like Affirm, Afterpay, and Klarna allow consumers to divide their purchases into smaller, interest-free payments over a set period. This setup may seem like a win-win situation, but the reality is far more complex.

The Allure and the Pitfalls of BNPL

BNPL plans are not installment agreements with the retailer; they are, in fact, lines of credit extended by third-party companies. This distinction is crucial because it means BNPL loans carry the same obligations and risks as any other loan, including the potential to damage your credit score.

One of the most significant pitfalls of BNPL is its ability to encourage overspending and impulse buying. The ease of splitting payments into manageable chunks can make a purchase seem more affordable than it truly is, leading consumers to buy items they might not otherwise afford. This behavior can quickly spiral into “loan stacking,” where consumers take out multiple BNPL loans across different lenders, often without fully realizing the financial commitment they are making. This overextension is a fast track to financial trouble, as missed payments can result in late fees, penalties, and damage to your credit score.

Hidden Fees, Lack of Consumer Protections, and Recent Updates

Another significant concern with BNPL services has been the lack of transparency and consumer protections compared to traditional loans or credit cards. While BNPL is often marketed as a hassle-free way to finance purchases, many users are caught off guard by hidden fees and unclear terms. Late fees can quickly accumulate, and some BNPL providers may charge interest rates higher than those on traditional credit cards if payments are missed.

However, an important update to BNPL regulations is on the horizon. On May 22, 2024, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) ruled that BNPL companies must provide consumers the right to dispute charges and demand refunds after returning a product, similar to the protections they have when using a credit card. While this new rule, expected to take effect this fall, will offer some additional safeguards, it does not eliminate the other risks associated with BNPL. Consumers must still navigate the varied terms and conditions of different providers, and the core issues of overspending, high fees, and potential credit damage remain prevalent.

The Benefits of Choosing Traditional Financing: Security, Savings, and Support

Given the risks associated with BNPL, it’s essential to consider safer and more reliable financing alternatives. Credit unions, like the U.S. Senate Federal credit Union (USSFCU), offer personal loans and credit cards that provide clear, regulated terms and valuable benefits. Unlike BNPL, credit cards can help you build credit when used responsibly. Plus, with a credit union credit card, you can manage your finances more effectively, knowing that you are protected by federal regulations and have access to member services that prioritize your financial well-being.

Personal loans from credit unions are another excellent alternative to BNPL. These loans offer fixed interest rates and repayment terms, giving you predictability and control over your finances. They are ideal for making larger purchases or consolidating debt, and because they are issued by a member-focused institution, you can expect lower fees and better customer service compared to other lenders.

Conclusion

While the new CFPB ruling may enhance some consumer protections for BNPL users, the risks and drawbacks of these services still make them a less-than-ideal choice for most consumers. Instead, consider the benefits of traditional financing options like credit cards and personal loans from your credit union. These options not only offer greater security and transparency but also provide long-term benefits that support your overall financial health. At USSFCU, we are committed to helping you make smart financial decisions that contribute to your financial success. Visit ussfcu.org/joinus to learn more.

ICYMI: You are Invited to Crumbl’s Grand Opening Pink Party –Free Cookies and Selfies with Baby Cow