Alexandria, VA – Dear Dr. Amy,
My daughter is getting married in September, and what started as a family group text to coordinate wedding plans has become a source of stress. Someone is upset about the guest list. Someone else feels left out of a pre-wedding event. A joke didn’t land well. A text got interpreted the wrong way. At this point, every time my phone buzzes, I brace myself. Why does a family group chat seem to make everything worse?
Sincerely,
Muted Until September
Dear Muted,
Every family wedding starts with love. And then somebody creates a group text.
At first, it’s a thing of beauty. Hotel information is shared. Bridal shower dates are coordinated. Somebody finds a great deal on welcome bags. It feels efficient, organized, and modern.
Then somebody misreads a message. Someone else doesn’t respond. A third person adds an opinion nobody asked for. And before long, we’re no longer discussing a wedding. We’re discussing feelings.
The problem is that family group chats are fantastic for logistics and terrible for relationships. Need to know where the rehearsal dinner is? Perfect. Need to discuss hurt feelings, family history, or why Cousin Jenny is upset about the seating chart? Not so much.
As a psychologist, I’ve noticed that most family conflicts aren’t actually about what they’re supposedly about. The argument about the guest list is rarely about the guest list. The disagreement about who was invited to which event is rarely about the invitation.
Underneath those conversations are much bigger questions:
Do I matter? Do I belong? Am I important to this family?
Those are meaningful conversations. They deserve more than a text bubble.
The challenge is that our brains fill in missing information. When we read a text, we don’t hear tone. We don’t see a smile. We don’t know whether someone was joking, distracted, stressed, or rushing between meetings. So we guess. And family members, with years of shared history, are particularly good at guessing wrong. Before long, people are responding to what they think was meant rather than what was actually said.
One of the healthiest things families can do is decide what belongs in the group chat and what doesn’t. Logistics belong in the group chat. The hotel address? Absolutely. The brunch time? Perfect. The family fantasy football draft? Go for it.
But feelings, they belong in conversations. Pick up the phone. Meet for coffee. Take a walk along the Potomac. Sit on the porch. Talk to the person instead of talking about the person.
As we head into wedding season, I think many families would benefit from remembering that technology is a wonderful tool for sharing information. It is not always the best tool for building connection. The strongest families are not the ones who avoid conflict. They are the ones willing to have real conversations when conflict inevitably shows up. And those conversations are usually much better face-to-face than they are sandwiched between a thumbs-up emoji and a meme that accidentally starts a totally different argument.
—Dr. Amy
Do you have a question about your family? Ask it here – https://bit.ly/3T0SFSm
